Guidelines and Policies

This page sets out the editorial and publication policies of the International Journal of Kinanthropometry (IJK). IJK follows the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME). Specific instructions for preparing manuscripts are given in the Submissions page.

Contents

IJK is a fully open-access journal. All articles are freely available to read, download and share immediately upon publication, without subscription or registration.

Authors retain copyright in their articles. By submitting a manuscript, authors grant IJK and its publisher, the International Society for the Advancement of Kinanthropometry (ISAK), a non-exclusive right of first publication.

Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence. Under this licence, anyone may copy, distribute, adapt and build upon the work, in any medium or format and for any purpose, including commercial purposes, provided that appropriate credit is given to the original authors and source, a link to the licence is provided, and any changes are indicated. The licence applicable to each article is stated on the article itself.

Further details are given in the Copyright Notice on the Submissions page.

Permission Requests

No additional permission from IJK or ISAK is normally required to reuse material published in IJK under CC BY 4.0, provided that the licence terms are followed. Third-party material reproduced in an article (for example, a figure reproduced from another publication) may not be covered by the article’s CC BY 4.0 licence; in such cases, permission may be needed from the relevant rights holder.

The CC BY 4.0 licence applies to published articles. It does not apply to the journal’s name, logo, website design or the ISAK name and logo, which remain the property of ISAK (see the Legal Notice).

Article Processing Charges

IJK does not charge submission fees, article processing charges (APCs) or publication fees. Publication in the journal is free of charge to authors. Articles are free of charge to readers.

Peer Review Policy

IJK operates a double-blind peer-review process: the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to each other. Editorials, which are published by invitation, are assessed by the editorial team and are not sent for external peer review.

Initial editorial assessment

Each submission is first assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or a delegated editor. This initial screening considers whether the manuscript falls within the aims and scope of the journal, whether it meets a minimum standard of scientific quality, and whether it complies with the journal’s editorial and ethical requirements, including the Author Guidelines, anonymisation for double-blind review and similarity checking. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or declined without external review.

External review

Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment are normally sent to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Editors take reasonable steps to avoid inviting reviewers who have a conflict of interest with the authors or the work. Reviewers are asked to treat the manuscript as confidential and to disclose any potential conflict of interest (see Guidelines for Reviewers). Anonymisation reduces the disclosure of identities but cannot by itself eliminate all sources of bias.

Editorial decisions

Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The handling editor makes a decision on the basis of the reviewer reports, the manuscript and the journal’s policies. Possible decisions include:

  • Accept;
  • Minor revision;
  • Major revision; or
  • Reject.

Reviewer comments are shared with the authors in anonymised form. Comments addressed confidentially to the editor are not shared. Final responsibility for editorial decisions rests with the Editor-in-Chief or the editor to whom that responsibility has been delegated. Submission or invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance, and the journal does not guarantee a particular review or publication time. Authors may appeal against a decision as described under Complaints and Appeals.

Revised submissions

Revised manuscripts must be submitted through the journal’s online submission system in accordance with the instructions provided in the editorial decision letter. Authors should provide a point-by-point response to the reviewers’ and editor’s comments and indicate the changes made in the manuscript. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or sent to additional reviewers where necessary.

Manuscripts by editors

Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, other members of the editorial team or ISAK officers are handled by an editor with no conflict of interest and undergo the same peer-review process as other submissions. The submitting editor takes no part in the handling of, or decision on, their own manuscript.

Proofs and Publication

Before publication, the corresponding author receives the proofs of the article for final checking. Proofs should be used only to correct typesetting errors and to verify the completeness and accuracy of the text, tables, figures and author information. Substantive changes to the accepted manuscript require the approval of the editor. Authors should return all corrections together, within the time indicated by the journal.

After publication, authors can share the final published article freely, using its DOI and in accordance with the CC BY 4.0 licence.

Authorship and Contributorship

IJK follows the authorship principles of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). All individuals listed as authors must meet the journal’s authorship criteria, and all individuals who meet those criteria should be listed as authors. All authors are expected to take responsibility for the integrity of the work and to approve the final version submitted for publication.

Qualification for Authorship

Authorship should be based on all four of the following criteria:

  1. substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis or interpretation of data for the work;
  2. drafting the work or reviewing it critically for important intellectual content;
  3. final approval of the version to be published; and
  4. agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

Acquisition of funding, collection of data or general supervision of a research group alone does not justify authorship. Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors (see Use of Artificial Intelligence).

Author Contributions

The individual contributions of all authors must be described using the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy). The corresponding author provides this information at submission, after all authors have agreed on their contributions. Author contributions are published with the article.

Group Authorship

When a manuscript is authored by a collaborative group or consortium, the group must identify the individuals who meet the authorship criteria and accept direct responsibility for the work; each of these individuals must complete the required declarations. The corresponding author should clearly indicate, on the title page, the group name and the individual authors in the form in which they should appear in the article and its metadata, to ensure appropriate attribution and indexing. Other members of the group who do not meet the authorship criteria may be listed in the Acknowledgements or in a collaborator statement.

Acknowledgements

Contributors who do not meet the criteria for authorship should be named in the Acknowledgements, with a brief description of their contribution. Authors are responsible for obtaining the permission of those acknowledged.

Corresponding Author Responsibilities

The corresponding author is the primary point of contact between the journal and the author group throughout the submission, peer-review and publication process. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that:

  • all listed authors meet the journal’s authorship criteria;
  • all authors have approved the submitted version of the manuscript;
  • the author list and author contributions are accurate;
  • all required declarations and disclosures have been provided;
  • all authors are informed of significant editorial correspondence and decisions; and
  • any request for an authorship change is supported by the written agreement of all affected authors.

After publication, the corresponding author should remain available to respond to reasonable questions about the published work and should inform co-authors of any issues requiring their attention.

Authorship Changes Policy

Authors should agree on the list and order of authors before submission. Any request to add, remove or reorder authors after submission must be made by the corresponding author, must explain the reason for the change and must be accompanied by the written agreement of all authors, including any author being added or removed. Requests made after acceptance are considered only in exceptional circumstances, and publication may be suspended while a request is assessed. IJK follows the relevant COPE guidance in such cases.

Authorship problems identified after publication may require a correction. IJK does not adjudicate authorship disputes. If the authors cannot resolve a dispute themselves, the journal may refer the matter to the relevant institution or institutions.

Responsibilities of Authors, Reviewers, Editors and Publisher

Authors

Authors are responsible for the accuracy, originality and integrity of the work they submit to the International Journal of Kinanthropometry (IJK). Authors must:

  • submit original work that has not been published previously and is not under consideration by another journal;
  • ensure that all data, analyses and interpretations are presented accurately and transparently;
  • appropriately acknowledge and cite the work of others;
  • ensure that all individuals listed as authors meet the journal’s authorship criteria;
  • disclose relevant conflicts of interest and sources of funding;
  • obtain appropriate ethical approval and informed consent where required;
  • disclose the use of artificial intelligence or AI-assisted technologies where applicable;
  • cooperate with the editorial and peer-review process and respond appropriately to reviewer and editor comments; and
  • promptly inform the journal if a significant error or concern is identified in a submitted or published article.

Authors remain responsible for the content of their work throughout the submission, review and publication process.

Reviewers

Reviewers are responsible for providing independent, constructive and confidential assessments of manuscripts within their areas of expertise. Reviewers must:

  • disclose any actual or potential conflict of interest;
  • decline a review when they do not have the appropriate expertise or cannot provide an impartial assessment;
  • treat manuscripts and associated materials as confidential;
  • evaluate submissions objectively and constructively;
  • avoid personal criticism of authors;
  • provide clear reasons for their recommendations;
  • identify relevant ethical, methodological or research-integrity concerns where appropriate; and
  • refrain from using unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal or professional advantage.

Reviewer recommendations are advisory. Final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the journal’s editors.

Editors

Editors are responsible for ensuring that manuscripts are evaluated fairly, independently and in accordance with the journal’s editorial policies. Editors must:

  • assess manuscripts on the basis of their scientific quality, relevance and compliance with the journal’s aims and scope, without regard to the authors’ sex, gender, ethnic or geographical origin, religion, citizenship or political views;
  • maintain the confidentiality of submitted material;
  • select appropriately qualified and independent reviewers;
  • identify and manage potential conflicts of interest;
  • ensure that editorial decisions are not influenced by commercial, personal or institutional considerations;
  • respond appropriately to concerns relating to research integrity, publication ethics or potential misconduct; and
  • make editorial decisions based on the manuscript, reviewer reports, authors’ responses and the journal’s policies.

The Editor-in-Chief retains responsibility for the final editorial decision.

Publisher

The International Society for the Advancement of Kinanthropometry (ISAK), as publisher of IJK, supports the editorial independence and integrity of the journal. The publisher works with the editorial team to maintain appropriate standards of scholarly publishing, transparency, publication ethics, accessibility and preservation of the scientific record. Editorial decisions concerning individual manuscripts are made independently by the journal’s editors on the basis of scientific and editorial considerations. Where concerns arise regarding published material, research integrity or publication ethics, IJK and its publisher will take appropriate action in accordance with the journal’s policies and relevant recognised guidelines for scholarly publishing.

Conflicts of Interest

A conflict of interest (or competing interest) exists when a financial or non-financial interest could reasonably be perceived as influencing the conduct or reporting of research, peer review or editorial decision-making. Such interests may be financial (for example, employment, consultancies, grants, honoraria, patents or shareholdings) or non-financial (for example, personal relationships, academic competition, institutional affiliations or strongly held beliefs relevant to the work). A declared interest does not necessarily prevent publication or participation in peer review, but it must be disclosed.

  • Authors must disclose any financial or non-financial interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the research, its interpretation or its publication. A conflict-of-interest statement is required for every submission; if no relevant competing interests exist, this must be stated explicitly. Declarations are published with the article.
  • Reviewers must disclose any relevant conflict of interest to the editor and decline the invitation when they cannot provide an impartial assessment, for example because of recent collaboration or co-authorship with the authors, a shared institutional affiliation, a personal relationship or a financial interest in the work.
  • Editors must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and recuse themselves from handling a manuscript when impartial handling cannot reasonably be ensured; the manuscript is then assigned to another editor. Editors should take conflicts of interest into account when selecting reviewers.

Undisclosed conflicts of interest identified after publication will be handled in accordance with COPE guidance and may result in a correction or, in serious cases, a retraction.

Research Ethics, Informed Consent and Animal Research

Research involving human participants

Research involving human participants, human material or identifiable human data must have been conducted in accordance with applicable laws, regulations and institutional requirements and, where relevant, with the principles of the World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki. Such research must have been approved by an appropriate research ethics committee or institutional review board (IRB) where approval is required. The manuscript must name the approving committee and give the approval reference number and date (in the anonymised manuscript, the committee name should be blinded for review).

If a study was exempt from ethics approval, the authors must state the reason for the exemption and identify the body that granted it or the regulation on which the exemption is based. Editors may request further information, including a copy of the approval, and may decline a manuscript if they have concerns about the ethical conduct of the research, even where approval has been obtained.

  • Informed consent must be obtained from all participants (or from a parent or legal guardian, as appropriate, in the case of minors or participants unable to consent), and the manuscript must state how consent was obtained.
  • Participants’ privacy and confidentiality must be protected. Manuscripts should not include names, initials, identifying details or images that could identify a participant unless the information is essential for scientific purposes.
  • Where identifiable information or images are essential, written informed consent for publication must be obtained from the participant (or parent or legal guardian), and the manuscript must state that such consent has been obtained. Consent forms should be retained by the authors and provided to the journal on request.
  • Case Studies require written informed consent from the participant (or parent or legal guardian) for publication.

Research involving animals

Research involving animals must comply with applicable institutional, national and international regulations and standards for the care and use of animals and must have been approved by an appropriate ethics committee where required. Authors should minimise harm to animals and follow recognised principles of animal welfare. The manuscript must include a statement of compliance and, where applicable, the name of the approving committee and the approval reference. Authors are encouraged to follow the ARRIVE guidelines when reporting animal research. Editors may decline manuscripts that raise concerns about animal welfare.

Reporting Guidelines and Data Availability

Authors should follow the reporting guideline appropriate to their study design, available from the EQUATOR Network; for example, STROBE for observational studies, CONSORT for randomised trials, PRISMA 2020 for systematic reviews and CARE for case reports. The guideline followed must be stated on the title page, and the completed checklist should be uploaded as a supplementary file at submission.

All manuscripts must include a data availability statement indicating whether and how the data supporting the findings can be accessed, or explaining any restrictions (for example, for reasons of participant confidentiality).

Use of Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies

IJK’s policy on artificial intelligence (AI) is aligned with the ICMJE Recommendations and COPE guidance.

Authors

  • AI systems, including large language models and chatbots, cannot be listed as authors, because they cannot take responsibility for the work or meet the authorship criteria.
  • Human authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality and integrity of the entire manuscript, including any content produced with the assistance of AI, and for ensuring appropriate attribution and the absence of plagiarism.
  • Authors must disclose any relevant use of AI-assisted technologies in the preparation of the manuscript (for example, for writing, translation, or the generation or editing of text, images or figures) in the declarations on the title page, stating the tool used and how it was used.
  • Where AI is used as part of the research methodology (for example, for data collection, analysis or image processing), it must be described in sufficient detail in the Methods section to allow evaluation and replication.
  • Routine use of spelling and grammar checkers does not need to be disclosed.

Editors and reviewers

  • Editors and reviewers must preserve the confidentiality of manuscripts and peer-review material.
  • Unpublished manuscripts, or any part of them, and peer-review reports must not be uploaded to external AI tools where confidentiality cannot be assured, unless the authors have given permission.
  • Editors and reviewers should be transparent about any permitted use of AI in their work and remain fully responsible for their assessments and decisions.

Publication Ethics and Research Misconduct

IJK is committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record and follows COPE guidance in handling concerns about publication ethics and research integrity, both before and after publication.

Concerns may include, for example:

  • plagiarism;
  • duplicate or redundant publication;
  • fabrication of data;
  • falsification of data or results;
  • inappropriate image manipulation;
  • authorship concerns;
  • undisclosed conflicts of interest; and
  • concerns about ethical approval or informed consent.

Anyone may raise a concern with the journal by writing to info@ijok.org, providing sufficient information to allow the concern to be assessed. Allegations are handled fairly and confidentially, and information is shared only with those who need it. The authors or other relevant parties are normally given the opportunity to respond.

The journal is not able to conduct a full investigation of research misconduct. Where serious concerns cannot be resolved by the journal, the matter may be referred to the authors’ institution, employer or another competent authority. Any action taken is decided case by case and is proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the concern; possible outcomes range from clarification or education of the authors to rejection of the manuscript, publication of a correction, an expression of concern or a retraction.

Similarity Checking and Plagiarism

All manuscripts submitted to IJK are screened for similarity using Crossref Similarity Check (powered by iThenticate).

A similarity score alone does not establish plagiarism. Similarity reports are assessed by the editors in context, taking into account the nature and location of the overlapping text, the sources involved and whether they are appropriately cited. Suspected plagiarism, including the unacknowledged reuse of the authors’ own published text, is handled in accordance with the Publication Ethics and Research Misconduct policy.

Corrections, Retractions and Other Changes to Published Articles

Published articles form part of the permanent scholarly record and are not altered after publication except as described below. IJK handles post-publication changes in accordance with the COPE Retraction Guidelines and the ICMJE Recommendations on corrections, retractions, republications and version control. Decisions are made by the editors, if necessary after consultation with the authors, reviewers or other experts. Authors’ retention of copyright does not give them a right to have a published article withdrawn or removed.

Correction

A correction is published when an honest error affects part of an otherwise reliable article, for example an error in data, a table or figure, or the author list, and the main findings and conclusions remain valid. Corrections are published as a separate, citable notice linked to the original article. Where appropriate, the article is updated and the correction is clearly indicated on the article page.

Retraction

An article may be retracted when there is clear evidence that its findings are unreliable, whether because of misconduct (such as data fabrication or falsification) or honest error, or when it constitutes plagiarism, redundant publication, or a serious breach of ethical or authorship standards. Retractions are published as a notice entitled “Retraction: [article title]”, which explains the reason for the retraction and states who requested it. The retraction notice and the original article are linked to each other. The retracted article remains available and is clearly marked as retracted, so that it remains identifiable as part of the scholarly record. Where concerns are under investigation, the journal may publish an expression of concern.

Withdrawal before publication

Authors may withdraw a manuscript at any time before it is accepted. After acceptance, withdrawal is possible only for exceptional reasons, which must be explained to and accepted by the editor. If an accepted article has been made available online before formal publication in an issue, its withdrawal will be handled transparently, in accordance with COPE guidance, with a notice explaining the withdrawal.

Removal

In exceptional circumstances, the content of a published article may be removed, for example where it is clearly defamatory, infringes the legal rights of others, is the subject of a court order, or could pose a serious risk to health if acted upon. In such cases, the bibliographic information about the article is retained, together with a notice explaining that the content has been removed and the reason for removal, as far as legally permissible.

Retraction and republication (replacement)

Where an honest error substantially changes the results or conclusions of an article but a corrected version is scientifically sound, the editors may decide to retract the original article and republish a corrected version. The retraction notice explains the reason for the change and is linked to both the original and the republished article, so that the history of the article remains transparent.

Complaints and Appeals

IJK aims to handle complaints and appeals fairly, consistently and in a documented manner, in accordance with COPE guidance. Complaints and appeals should be sent to info@ijok.org, stating the manuscript or article concerned (title and, where available, submission ID or DOI) and the grounds for the complaint or appeal. Receipt will be acknowledged, and the complainant will be informed of the outcome and, where relevant, of the action taken.

Complaints about editorial processes or conduct

Complaints may concern the journal’s processes or the conduct of its editors, reviewers or staff, for example undue delay, failure to follow the journal’s published policies or inappropriate behaviour. Such complaints are reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief or, if the complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief or the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, by another senior editor or by the publisher, ISAK. Where a complaint is upheld, the journal will take appropriate corrective action.

Appeals against editorial decisions

Authors who believe that a decision on their manuscript was based on a factual error, a misunderstanding of the work, or a failure to follow the journal’s procedures may submit an appeal. The appeal should explain clearly why the decision should be reconsidered and respond specifically to the reasons given for it. Appeals are assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision, who may consult the original or additional reviewers. Disagreement with reviewers’ or editors’ scientific judgement alone is not usually sufficient grounds for an appeal. Only one appeal per manuscript will be considered, and the manuscript will not be considered under review while the appeal is assessed. The outcome of the appeal is final.

Ethical and research-integrity complaints

Concerns about plagiarism, data integrity, authorship, ethics approval, conflicts of interest or other possible misconduct in submitted or published work are handled under the Publication Ethics and Research Misconduct policy. Complaints about published content that may be unlawful (for example, infringement of intellectual property rights or defamation) can also be addressed to the publisher, as indicated in the Legal Notice.

Advertising Policy

IJK does not currently carry commercial advertising on its website or in its articles. Should the journal accept advertising in the future, advertising will be clearly distinguishable from editorial content, will have no influence on editorial decisions, and will not imply endorsement by IJK, ISAK, the Editor-in-Chief or the editorial team. This policy will be updated before any advertising is introduced.

Repository Policy

Authors may share and deposit the submitted manuscript (preprint) and the accepted manuscript in institutional or subject repositories, on preprint servers or on personal websites at any time and without embargo, in accordance with the rights they retain. Where possible, these versions should state that the manuscript has been submitted to, or accepted by, IJK and, after publication, link to the published article.

The final published version (Version of Record) is distributed under the CC BY 4.0 licence and may be deposited or shared immediately upon publication. When sharing the Version of Record, the article should be cited correctly and linked through its DOI.

Digital Archiving Policy

IJK intends to preserve its published content in the Public Knowledge Project Preservation Network (PKP PN). The journal has accepted the network’s terms of use, but preservation deposits have not yet started; this policy will be updated when preservation is active. Published articles and their metadata remain openly available on the journal website and can be harvested through the OAI-PMH protocol.

Guidelines for Reviewers

Peer reviewers make an essential contribution to the quality of the journal. IJK operates double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to each other. This reduces the disclosure of identities but cannot by itself ensure an entirely objective and unbiased assessment; reviewers are therefore asked to be aware of possible sources of bias in their own judgement. Reviewers are asked to:

  • accept an invitation only if the manuscript falls within their area of expertise and they can complete the review within the agreed deadline, informing the editor promptly if they need more time;
  • disclose any potential conflict of interest and decline the invitation if they cannot provide an impartial assessment, or inform the editor if they believe they can identify the authors;
  • treat the manuscript and all associated material as confidential, not share it with others without the editor’s permission, and not upload it to external AI tools where confidentiality cannot be assured;
  • provide an objective, constructive and respectful report, avoiding personal criticism of the authors;
  • assess the originality of the work, its relevance to the scope of the journal, the appropriateness of the methodology and statistical analysis, the interpretation of the results and whether the conclusions are supported by the data, and the quality and completeness of reporting, including adherence to the relevant reporting guideline and, where applicable, the ISAK anthropometric measurement standards;
  • identify relevant published work that has not been cited, where appropriate, without requesting citations to their own work unless clearly justified;
  • inform the editor confidentially of any ethical or research-integrity concerns, such as suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or falsification, or lack of ethics approval; and
  • not use unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal or professional advantage.

Detailed instructions and the evaluation criteria are provided to reviewers in the online review system. Reviewers should also follow the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.